The Good Fairy – Part 2 of 2

The trash can in the third floor men’s room in Charlotte’s city hall was a gold mine.

All sorts of documents were tossed into that can, 0ld records, current records too, slightly delayed. The typewriters used by the secretaries for the mayor and the city manger had once-through carbons and, every few days, they changed the carbon and threw the old one away. You could hold them up the a light and read every word they had typed.

Try to imagine Christmas coming twice a week. That’s the way it was for the fulltime city hall reporter, and me, too, when I filled in for him.

To help protect this source from discovery we called it “The Good Fairy.”    We never talked about where those documents came from –the less said the better– we’d just say they were a gift from the Good Fairy.

One afternoon she smiled on me. In the trash can in the men’s room I found a copy of the city’s plan to break the next garbage strike. That’s a 1A lead.  The problem was, publishing a story about how the city planned to break a strike might precipitate a strike — which we did not want to do. We wanted to cover news, not make it.

My editor, Perry Morgan, had reservations about publishing it, but he left the call up to me. I thought about it and decided to try to have my cake and eat it too.

Bill Veeder was the city manager back then.  By all accounts, he did an excellent job.  But for some reason I never got along with him; he didn’t like me, from the very beginning.

The first time he laid eyes on me — I was fresh out of college and had just gone to work in the “foreign office” in the basement of City Hall, covering county government — he stood in front my desk and told another reporter, “This one’s not going to make it,” meaning me.

Two years later when I switched beats and started covering city hall I did everything I could to turn him around, to no avail. I even tried being extra nice, which was not exactly my nature.

And now I had him in a vice.

I telephoned him and I said, “Bill, I have a copy of your plan to break the next garbage strike. I’m going to put it in the paper this afternoon. Do you have any comment?”

And he said, “No, you don’t.”

And I said, “Oh, yes, I do, Bill. Would you like me to read it to you?”

I didn’t have to read long before he stopped me and asked — his tone was low and ugly — “What do you want?”

Now we’re getting down to business. That mean man was going to have to deal and I must tell you — I loved it.

There were two 1A stories on the horizon that I wanted, and I wanted him to see to it that I got both them first — before any of my competition. Give me those two stories, I told him, and I won’t write about the strike breaking plan until you actually have a strike.

He agreed, and he delivered. Twice in the next couple of weeks his secretary came down to the foreign office, handed me a brown envelope and, “Mr. Veeder said this is for you.”

It was delicious.

Postscript:  The Good Fairy was finally exposed by an unhappy reporter who had been fired. But she sure was good to us while she lasted.

Coming Monday: “Emergency Landing!”

The Good Fairy – Part 1 of 2

When I stopped by a tiny windowless room in the basement of City Hall in Charlotte — a place reporters who worked at The Charlotte News called the “foreign office” — the door was closed.

And locked.

The three News reporters who covered city government, county governments, and courts and cops, worked there.  It had been my office for three years before I was moved to the downtown office and I don’t remember us ever closing the door during the day. We certainly didn’t lock it.

I knocked.

I heard someone say, “Just a minute.” When the reporter who had taken my place covering the city finally opened the door I could see he was relieved to see it was just me.

He closed and locked the door again and began unbuttoning his shirt — it was puffed out, like he had gained 25 or 30 pounds — and began pulling out what looked like letters, torn in half, and piling them on his desk.

He was one happy guy because he had accidently discovered a cache of discarded government documents.

He had gone to the bathroom in the men’s room on the third floor of City Hall, washed his hands, dried them with a paper towel, and tried to stuff it in the waste paper basket, but there was no room. It was full, but not full of paper towels. Sticking out the top was what looked to him like letters, reports.

Charlotte Mayor Stan Brookshire was going out of office soon and someone was cleaning out his files. Papers that had been discarded in his waste basket had been emptied into the much larger trash can in the Men’s Room.

The documents were public records* under North Carolina law. Still, they were the kind of records that were difficult, if not impossible, to obtain. You can’t ask to inspect, or copy, a  letter or report you don’t know exists.

Working together we emptied the trash can in the Men’s Room, took everything to my colleague’s apartment, and  taped the letters and other documents back together.

We were rewarded with leads on two or three OK stories. But the best was yet to come.

My colleague called me the next week and told me the good news: the trash can in the third floor Men’s Room was the mother lode.  A janitor emptied the waste baskets from the offices of the mayor, the city manager, and their secretaries into that big trash can every day.

What a source!  We named it the “Good Fairy.”

Continued tomorrow.

* North Carolina General Statute 132.1:

“‘Public record’ or ‘public records’ shall mean all documents, papers, letters, maps, books, photographs, films, sound recordings, magnetic or other tapes, electronic data-processing records, artifacts, or other documentary material, regardless of physical form or characteristics, made or received pursuant to law or ordinance in connection with the transaction of public business by any agency of North Carolina government or its subdivisions.

“The public records and public information compiled by the agencies of North Carolina government or its subdivisions are property of the people.”

There are a number of exceptions to G.S. 132.1, for example: medical records; tax returns; SBI investigative reports; the state auditor’s audit work papers; and certain personnel records of public employees.